Boxee

Adding Airplay / Airtunes (from Apple) to the BB

Details

  • Severity:
    Major
  • Version:
    1.0.2.16619
  • Operating System:
    Boxee Box
  • Number of attachments:
    0

Description

AirPlay/AirTunes lets you stream music throughout your entire house — wirelessly

Airplay would allow the BB to receive stream musique/film from your iPad/iPhone... to the BB

EX: I start to watcha movie in the train and I can finish to watch it on my BB same for musique ;-)

AirPlay is open source

Activity

Hide
Rafael Mizrahi [Boxee] added a comment - 19/Dec/10 5:05 AM
This issue is awaiting review from Boxee Product Management.
If you are keen to have this feature implemented, please Comment and Vote for it.
Show
Rafael Mizrahi [Boxee] added a comment - 19/Dec/10 5:05 AM This issue is awaiting review from Boxee Product Management. If you are keen to have this feature implemented, please Comment and Vote for it.
Hide
CP added a comment - 20/Dec/10 10:34 PM
This would be great, here is some information on an implementation of exactly this for XBMC that might be a good starting point for an implementation in Boxee:

http://www.tuaw.com/2010/12/20/airplay-running-on-xbmc-linux-box/
Show
CP added a comment - 20/Dec/10 10:34 PM This would be great, here is some information on an implementation of exactly this for XBMC that might be a good starting point for an implementation in Boxee: http://www.tuaw.com/2010/12/20/airplay-running-on-xbmc-linux-box/
Hide
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 25/Dec/10 4:32 AM
It would be a killer feature and should definitely be implemented. Lots of users that have BoxeeBox will not even realize that they can vote for features etc but if let's say someone wants a box that has Netflix for example and supposedly Boxee will get it soon.... and they have an iDevice, they'll most likely get the AppleTV because of this feature alone. Implementing it would even out the playing field and considering there are so many devices out there that post videos on tv etc... this would really help Boxee differentiate itself! I say go for it if possible guys.

Thanks!
Show
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 25/Dec/10 4:32 AM It would be a killer feature and should definitely be implemented. Lots of users that have BoxeeBox will not even realize that they can vote for features etc but if let's say someone wants a box that has Netflix for example and supposedly Boxee will get it soon.... and they have an iDevice, they'll most likely get the AppleTV because of this feature alone. Implementing it would even out the playing field and considering there are so many devices out there that post videos on tv etc... this would really help Boxee differentiate itself! I say go for it if possible guys. Thanks!
Hide
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 25/Dec/10 4:45 AM
I agree that would be a killer feature compare to competition !!! And if you guys support Air Print too people would be able to print from websites too !
Show
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 25/Dec/10 4:45 AM I agree that would be a killer feature compare to competition !!! And if you guys support Air Print too people would be able to print from websites too !
Hide
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 25/Dec/10 4:50 AM
AirPrint = whatever...

I understand bringing features that are good for the living room but AirPrint? About 80-90% of people have this in the living room... without a printer attached. you need drivers etc... and 1GB of NAND is not enough... and it's also pointless... most people have computers with printers attached to them and if they want airprint they can use their iphone for it. I don't see the point of AirPrint in boxee... this is not an all purpose computer replacement but a media center... not an office all around computer
Show
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 25/Dec/10 4:50 AM AirPrint = whatever... I understand bringing features that are good for the living room but AirPrint? About 80-90% of people have this in the living room... without a printer attached. you need drivers etc... and 1GB of NAND is not enough... and it's also pointless... most people have computers with printers attached to them and if they want airprint they can use their iphone for it. I don't see the point of AirPrint in boxee... this is not an all purpose computer replacement but a media center... not an office all around computer
Hide
Mark Duinhoven added a comment - 26/Dec/10 10:31 AM
+1 Really want Airplay/ Airtunes was kind of disapointed to find it wasn't possible on the BoxeeBox since I have seen it work in XMBC
Getting less and less impressed by the feature set. Especialy here in Europe.
Show
Mark Duinhoven added a comment - 26/Dec/10 10:31 AM +1 Really want Airplay/ Airtunes was kind of disapointed to find it wasn't possible on the BoxeeBox since I have seen it work in XMBC Getting less and less impressed by the feature set. Especialy here in Europe.
Hide
markus hübner added a comment - 26/Dec/10 11:16 AM
This is a worldwide renown feature, already many AV Receivers have it
Show
markus hübner added a comment - 26/Dec/10 11:16 AM This is a worldwide renown feature, already many AV Receivers have it
Hide
Brian Leach added a comment - 03/Jan/11 5:01 PM
+1 this would be awesome
Show
Brian Leach added a comment - 03/Jan/11 5:01 PM +1 this would be awesome
Hide
Julian Scarfe added a comment - 03/Jan/11 5:54 PM
+1; anyway to make itunes content more accessible to boxee
Show
Julian Scarfe added a comment - 03/Jan/11 5:54 PM +1; anyway to make itunes content more accessible to boxee
Hide
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 04/Jan/11 7:49 AM - edited
Here is a quote from the Boxee box forum that could be helpful :

http://forums.boxee.tv/showthread.php?p=143687

[QUOTE=StevenR;143685]I've taken a look at the Python code, and it might be possible to convert it to be able to run on the Boxee Box. It [b]is[/b] possible to run Python scripts on the Boxee Box, due to two things:

1) Boxee applications are based on Python and can be developed to run a Python file instead of displaying a window.
2) If an application runs a Python file and that file contains long running code (e.g. an infinite loop), the code will be running in the background even when that application is exited.

Providing the Python code is compatible with the Boxee Box, it could be turned into a Boxee application with the only issue being that you need to start that application every time the Box is restarted. I've already successfully done this with a Python script for a simple web server.

There is another issue with running it on the Boxee Box - a lot of the HTTP commands have been removed, including the PlayFile command which the script relies on. However, with the script running directly in Boxee, it should be possible to create an updated Boxee_media_backend.py file which directly uses the Boxee Python API to implement the same functionality.

I'll have another dig through the code and see how feasible this might be.[/QUOTE]
Show
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 04/Jan/11 7:49 AM - edited Here is a quote from the Boxee box forum that could be helpful : http://forums.boxee.tv/showthread.php?p=143687 [QUOTE=StevenR;143685]I've taken a look at the Python code, and it might be possible to convert it to be able to run on the Boxee Box. It [b]is[/b] possible to run Python scripts on the Boxee Box, due to two things: 1) Boxee applications are based on Python and can be developed to run a Python file instead of displaying a window. 2) If an application runs a Python file and that file contains long running code (e.g. an infinite loop), the code will be running in the background even when that application is exited. Providing the Python code is compatible with the Boxee Box, it could be turned into a Boxee application with the only issue being that you need to start that application every time the Box is restarted. I've already successfully done this with a Python script for a simple web server. There is another issue with running it on the Boxee Box - a lot of the HTTP commands have been removed, including the PlayFile command which the script relies on. However, with the script running directly in Boxee, it should be possible to create an updated Boxee_media_backend.py file which directly uses the Boxee Python API to implement the same functionality. I'll have another dig through the code and see how feasible this might be.[/QUOTE]
Hide
Arjan Schrijver added a comment - 06/Jan/11 9:43 AM
May be you can set Boxee Box as an Remote for iTunes on you're pc/mac, like this one:
http://itunes.apple.com/nl/app/remote/id284417350?mt=8
Show
Arjan Schrijver added a comment - 06/Jan/11 9:43 AM May be you can set Boxee Box as an Remote for iTunes on you're pc/mac, like this one: http://itunes.apple.com/nl/app/remote/id284417350?mt=8
Hide
Peter Aquinde added a comment - 07/Jan/11 4:19 PM
Yes, I would SO like this feature in the BB. Airtunes more than Airplay, but that's just me.
Show
Peter Aquinde added a comment - 07/Jan/11 4:19 PM Yes, I would SO like this feature in the BB. Airtunes more than Airplay, but that's just me.
Hide
Salomon Meij added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:09 PM
I would love this, as well.
Show
Salomon Meij added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:09 PM I would love this, as well.
Hide
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:32 PM
Air play is video and audio knowed before as AirPlay with only audio
Show
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:32 PM Air play is video and audio knowed before as AirPlay with only audio
Hide
Tyson Edwards added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:35 PM
AirPlay would be highly beneficial...
In any case, it has been shown that DRMed content can be presented live without said DRM to a third-party AirPlay device. The idea there being that the content is simply being "displayed" there, and not actually stored there.

People with iTunes Purchases could find themselves with an easier change-over if they found themselves with AirPlay on Boxee, as it would enable them to keep access to their entire media library in the change-over to new hardware.
Show
Tyson Edwards added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:35 PM AirPlay would be highly beneficial... In any case, it has been shown that DRMed content can be presented live without said DRM to a third-party AirPlay device. The idea there being that the content is simply being "displayed" there, and not actually stored there. People with iTunes Purchases could find themselves with an easier change-over if they found themselves with AirPlay on Boxee, as it would enable them to keep access to their entire media library in the change-over to new hardware.
Hide
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:43 PM
Maybe it's all ready coming as on the demo of the Boxee iPad app they are showing some kind of airplay
Show
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 09/Jan/11 12:43 PM Maybe it's all ready coming as on the demo of the Boxee iPad app they are showing some kind of airplay
Hide
markus hübner added a comment - 09/Jan/11 2:07 PM
Why is the priority of this bug "minor" when so many users are demanding it and there are an amazing 55 votes for it?!! Should be really adressed for SP4 parallel to when the boxee Box iPad App. will be released about that time.
Show
markus hübner added a comment - 09/Jan/11 2:07 PM Why is the priority of this bug "minor" when so many users are demanding it and there are an amazing 55 votes for it?!! Should be really adressed for SP4 parallel to when the boxee Box iPad App. will be released about that time.
Hide
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 09/Jan/11 2:15 PM
If they could listen to you !

The work as all ready been done for SMBC so it should work on Boxee
Show
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 09/Jan/11 2:15 PM If they could listen to you ! The work as all ready been done for SMBC so it should work on Boxee
Hide
Jens K added a comment - 14/Jan/11 9:56 AM
+1
Show
Jens K added a comment - 14/Jan/11 9:56 AM +1
Hide
Matthias Gevers added a comment - 17/Jan/11 9:21 AM
I am also very interested in Airplay so this would be the reason not to buy AppleTV
Show
Matthias Gevers added a comment - 17/Jan/11 9:21 AM I am also very interested in Airplay so this would be the reason not to buy AppleTV
Hide
Tom Beech added a comment - 19/Jan/11 8:38 AM
+1 for me, this is a must have feature.
Show
Tom Beech added a comment - 19/Jan/11 8:38 AM +1 for me, this is a must have feature.
Hide
Mathew Winstone added a comment - 27/Jan/11 9:52 PM
Definitely +1 for me. If I could vote more than once I would :-)
Show
Mathew Winstone added a comment - 27/Jan/11 9:52 PM Definitely +1 for me. If I could vote more than once I would :-)
Hide
Pascal Vantrepote added a comment - 31/Jan/11 10:12 PM - edited
Same here, this feature will be really useful.
This Python script is working on OSX (https://github.com/PascalW/Airplayer) but not with the BB.
I hope its help.
Show
Pascal Vantrepote added a comment - 31/Jan/11 10:12 PM - edited Same here, this feature will be really useful. This Python script is working on OSX (https://github.com/PascalW/Airplayer) but not with the BB. I hope its help.
Hide
Joeri De Haes added a comment - 03/Feb/11 6:50 AM
+1 for me to. Would love this feature.
Show
Joeri De Haes added a comment - 03/Feb/11 6:50 AM +1 for me to. Would love this feature.
Hide
Olly Stedall added a comment - 16/Feb/11 12:38 AM
+1 Add my vote for this!
Show
Olly Stedall added a comment - 16/Feb/11 12:38 AM +1 Add my vote for this!
Hide
Sven added a comment - 24/Feb/11 8:58 AM
+1 would be a killer feature
Show
Sven added a comment - 24/Feb/11 8:58 AM +1 would be a killer feature
Hide
Bart ten Brinke added a comment - 27/Feb/11 2:11 PM
+1. This or will be buying me an airport extreme really soon.
Show
Bart ten Brinke added a comment - 27/Feb/11 2:11 PM +1. This or will be buying me an airport extreme really soon.
Hide
Olly Stedall added a comment - 28/Feb/11 11:06 AM
The Boxee Get Satisfaction page has some more ideas on this: http://getsatisfaction.com/boxee/topics/add_itunes_airplay_support_to_boxee
Show
Olly Stedall added a comment - 28/Feb/11 11:06 AM The Boxee Get Satisfaction page has some more ideas on this: http://getsatisfaction.com/boxee/topics/add_itunes_airplay_support_to_boxee
Hide
Jorge Serna added a comment - 28/Feb/11 11:43 AM
+1 for me too
Show
Jorge Serna added a comment - 28/Feb/11 11:43 AM +1 for me too
Hide
Gercek added a comment - 28/Feb/11 2:10 PM
This should be TOP priority for Boxee Box!
Show
Gercek added a comment - 28/Feb/11 2:10 PM This should be TOP priority for Boxee Box!
Hide
Arash Negari added a comment - 01/Mar/11 6:22 AM
+1
Show
Arash Negari added a comment - 01/Mar/11 6:22 AM +1
Hide
Sean Cavanaugh added a comment - 02/Mar/11 2:54 PM
this would kill the apple tv in its tracks :)
Show
Sean Cavanaugh added a comment - 02/Mar/11 2:54 PM this would kill the apple tv in its tracks :)
Hide
Steve Copous added a comment - 02/Mar/11 7:29 PM
Would absolutely love to see this on the Boxee Box.
Show
Steve Copous added a comment - 02/Mar/11 7:29 PM Would absolutely love to see this on the Boxee Box.
Hide
Riyad Chowdhury added a comment - 02/Mar/11 8:44 PM
With the new features coming out on iOS 4.3, I would LOVE to have airplay on the Boxee Box. The new Xtreamer box thats coming out features airplay support, I think boxee should add it too!

http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/24/xtreamer-prodigy-features-airplay-support-usb-3-and-a-gui-that/
Show
Riyad Chowdhury added a comment - 02/Mar/11 8:44 PM With the new features coming out on iOS 4.3, I would LOVE to have airplay on the Boxee Box. The new Xtreamer box thats coming out features airplay support, I think boxee should add it too! http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/24/xtreamer-prodigy-features-airplay-support-usb-3-and-a-gui-that/
Hide
markus hübner added a comment - 08/Mar/11 1:13 PM
Demand increases, any chance to get this into 1.1?
Show
markus hübner added a comment - 08/Mar/11 1:13 PM Demand increases, any chance to get this into 1.1?
Hide
Sean Tauber added a comment - 08/Mar/11 11:20 PM
+1 This would be awesome!
Show
Sean Tauber added a comment - 08/Mar/11 11:20 PM +1 This would be awesome!
Hide
Jason added a comment - 09/Mar/11 12:12 AM
Would also love to see this addition. Holding out on the purchase of a Boxee Box to see if this feature makes it or not.
Show
Jason added a comment - 09/Mar/11 12:12 AM Would also love to see this addition. Holding out on the purchase of a Boxee Box to see if this feature makes it or not.
Hide
Mike L. added a comment - 09/Mar/11 1:42 PM
This would be awesome!
Show
Mike L. added a comment - 09/Mar/11 1:42 PM This would be awesome!
Hide
joe morrissey added a comment - 10/Mar/11 9:15 AM
There is a python script available for this, that Boxxe app dev could use to incorporate into the official ( esp boxee box) firmware.. c'mon boxee http://pwiddershoven.nl/blog/2011/01/05/airplayer.html
Show
joe morrissey added a comment - 10/Mar/11 9:15 AM There is a python script available for this, that Boxxe app dev could use to incorporate into the official ( esp boxee box) firmware.. c'mon boxee http://pwiddershoven.nl/blog/2011/01/05/airplayer.html
Hide
Peter added a comment - 10/Mar/11 9:37 AM
Is any one from Boxee going to Comment on this Feature??? Its very annoying that the Boxee team is not more forthcoming with if they are working on requests or not. We want more information from the Boxee team, stop leaving us in the dark!
Show
Peter added a comment - 10/Mar/11 9:37 AM Is any one from Boxee going to Comment on this Feature??? Its very annoying that the Boxee team is not more forthcoming with if they are working on requests or not. We want more information from the Boxee team, stop leaving us in the dark!
Hide
joe morrissey added a comment - 10/Mar/11 10:05 AM
I second Peter's comment above
Show
joe morrissey added a comment - 10/Mar/11 10:05 AM I second Peter's comment above
Hide
Ben Perlman added a comment - 14/Mar/11 1:13 PM
Should absolutely be top priority. Would love comment from Boxee on this.
Show
Ben Perlman added a comment - 14/Mar/11 1:13 PM Should absolutely be top priority. Would love comment from Boxee on this.
Hide
Jeremy Milum added a comment - 14/Mar/11 7:10 PM
Airplay would require a license from Apple, I'm not sure what the cost for that license would be, but the Boxee Box is a direct competitor to the Apple TV.
Show
Jeremy Milum added a comment - 14/Mar/11 7:10 PM Airplay would require a license from Apple, I'm not sure what the cost for that license would be, but the Boxee Box is a direct competitor to the Apple TV.
Hide
Charles ONeill added a comment - 15/Mar/11 12:16 AM
I would kill for this feature and not just with the boxee app please.
Show
Charles ONeill added a comment - 15/Mar/11 12:16 AM I would kill for this feature and not just with the boxee app please.
Hide
Pete Beaumont added a comment - 23/Mar/11 6:58 PM
Show
Pete Beaumont added a comment - 23/Mar/11 6:58 PM Apple Is Said to Weigh Expanding AirPlay For Streaming Video on Devices http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-03-23/apple-is-said-to-weigh-expanding-airplay-for-streaming-video-on-devices.html
Hide
joewest added a comment - 25/Mar/11 4:13 AM
+1
Show
joewest added a comment - 25/Mar/11 4:13 AM +1
Hide
egon0119 added a comment - 29/Mar/11 3:25 PM
This would be a great addition to the BB. +1
Show
egon0119 added a comment - 29/Mar/11 3:25 PM This would be a great addition to the BB. +1
Hide
Geir Borch added a comment - 31/Mar/11 3:40 AM
I would love to get this feature. It would give such a larger value to an already great system.
Show
Geir Borch added a comment - 31/Mar/11 3:40 AM I would love to get this feature. It would give such a larger value to an already great system.
Hide
Brett Biba added a comment - 08/Apr/11 12:54 AM
Is this request for the Boxee App too or just Boxee Box? I'd love to see it in the Boxee app as well.
Show
Brett Biba added a comment - 08/Apr/11 12:54 AM Is this request for the Boxee App too or just Boxee Box? I'd love to see it in the Boxee app as well.
Hide
Justin Lewis added a comment - 09/Apr/11 11:56 AM
Please implement!
Show
Justin Lewis added a comment - 09/Apr/11 11:56 AM Please implement!
Hide
Julian Scarfe added a comment - 12/Apr/11 3:16 PM
note this new, reverse-engineered library: http://mafipulation.org/blagoblig/2011/04/08#shairport
Show
Julian Scarfe added a comment - 12/Apr/11 3:16 PM note this new, reverse-engineered library: http://mafipulation.org/blagoblig/2011/04/08#shairport
Hide
Rebecca added a comment - 20/Apr/11 6:32 AM
This would be an awesome addition to Boxee! Jeremy Milum is right that it would require a license fee (I hope Boxee goes this route instead of the reverse-engineered library available on github). My guess is that Apple won't care that Boxee Box is a direct competitor with Apple TV. With licensing, they have the potential to make greater inroads into a person's family/living room than with Apple TV. If Apple TV were selling as well as iPhones and iPads, that might be a different story. Licensing could bring in a lot more money than Apple TV ever would, especially if they do go forward with licensing video streaming like they have with audio streaming.

In case Boxee does go the reverse-engineered library route, from http://www.mafipulation.org/:
Update: 13/4
So, this does everything I want, and I don't intend to issue any further releases here. Official development continues on github in albertz's github repo. Mac support, bug fixes and more!

NB: albertz's github repo: https://github.com/albertz/shairport
Show
Rebecca added a comment - 20/Apr/11 6:32 AM This would be an awesome addition to Boxee! Jeremy Milum is right that it would require a license fee (I hope Boxee goes this route instead of the reverse-engineered library available on github). My guess is that Apple won't care that Boxee Box is a direct competitor with Apple TV. With licensing, they have the potential to make greater inroads into a person's family/living room than with Apple TV. If Apple TV were selling as well as iPhones and iPads, that might be a different story. Licensing could bring in a lot more money than Apple TV ever would, especially if they do go forward with licensing video streaming like they have with audio streaming. In case Boxee does go the reverse-engineered library route, from http://www.mafipulation.org/: Update: 13/4 So, this does everything I want, and I don't intend to issue any further releases here. Official development continues on github in albertz's github repo. Mac support, bug fixes and more! NB: albertz's github repo: https://github.com/albertz/shairport
Hide
lior added a comment - 20/Apr/11 9:25 AM
That's ridiculous, there ain't need to pay fee or reverse engineer anything. there is already working implementation of Airplay Support here:
https://github.com/PascalW/Airplayer
It works for me great on my linux XBMC machine and it should work as well on the Boxee box because it based on it (XBMC+Linux)
Show
lior added a comment - 20/Apr/11 9:25 AM That's ridiculous, there ain't need to pay fee or reverse engineer anything. there is already working implementation of Airplay Support here: https://github.com/PascalW/Airplayer It works for me great on my linux XBMC machine and it should work as well on the Boxee box because it based on it (XBMC+Linux)
Hide
Julian Scarfe added a comment - 20/Apr/11 10:52 AM
one more thought on shairport reverse-engineered solution: Would Boxee be willing to add required dependencies to the build, allowing a 3rd party to more easily make an app (and accept the legal risk) w/ shairport functionality?
Show
Julian Scarfe added a comment - 20/Apr/11 10:52 AM one more thought on shairport reverse-engineered solution: Would Boxee be willing to add required dependencies to the build, allowing a 3rd party to more easily make an app (and accept the legal risk) w/ shairport functionality?
Hide
Terry Gregg added a comment - 22/Apr/11 8:32 PM
Great idea. Would integrate Boxee with a major part of entertainment streaming in the house.
Show
Terry Gregg added a comment - 22/Apr/11 8:32 PM Great idea. Would integrate Boxee with a major part of entertainment streaming in the house.
Hide
dave added a comment - 30/Apr/11 7:19 PM
+1 Airplay!
Show
dave added a comment - 30/Apr/11 7:19 PM +1 Airplay!
Hide
markus hübner added a comment - 05/May/11 12:43 PM
So dev team, what's the current status of this highly demanded feature? Any Chance to get this into 1.1?
Show
markus hübner added a comment - 05/May/11 12:43 PM So dev team, what's the current status of this highly demanded feature? Any Chance to get this into 1.1?
Hide
Yuval Tal [Boxee] added a comment - 05/May/11 2:55 PM
Apple is currently not licensing this for software companies.
Show
Yuval Tal [Boxee] added a comment - 05/May/11 2:55 PM Apple is currently not licensing this for software companies.
Hide
lior added a comment - 05/May/11 3:12 PM
That's the problem with Boxee became too much commercial platform.
I don't remember that apple complained or sued anyone in XBMC for allowing this kind of apps.
Boxee devs! Just open the web control and let apps root access and the open community will develop it if you can't.
Show
lior added a comment - 05/May/11 3:12 PM That's the problem with Boxee became too much commercial platform. I don't remember that apple complained or sued anyone in XBMC for allowing this kind of apps. Boxee devs! Just open the web control and let apps root access and the open community will develop it if you can't.
Hide
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 05/May/11 3:17 PM
Yuvalt, if they don't licensed Airplay how come many product are all ready on sale with that functionality ? Like home cinemas, DVD player, Stereos......
Show
Cedric Tomas added a comment - 05/May/11 3:17 PM Yuvalt, if they don't licensed Airplay how come many product are all ready on sale with that functionality ? Like home cinemas, DVD player, Stereos......
Hide
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 05/May/11 3:31 PM
@lior and lose Netflix and Vudu and others cause they don't think the platform is secure enough... no thanks... get an HTPC if you want "openness"
Show
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 05/May/11 3:31 PM @lior and lose Netflix and Vudu and others cause they don't think the platform is secure enough... no thanks... get an HTPC if you want "openness"
Hide
lior added a comment - 05/May/11 3:49 PM
The security of Boxee is an illusion, all of the code & keys are in the iso file of Boxee's version.
If Netflix want to protect it's code it should protect the servers and leave the client open.
I just think the boxee devs are too careful with licensing and infringement and they losing so many good features and apps.
Show
lior added a comment - 05/May/11 3:49 PM The security of Boxee is an illusion, all of the code & keys are in the iso file of Boxee's version. If Netflix want to protect it's code it should protect the servers and leave the client open. I just think the boxee devs are too careful with licensing and infringement and they losing so many good features and apps.
Hide
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 07/May/11 5:51 AM
If the keys are in the ISO why hasn't it been hacked yet to run XBMC?
Show
Stefan Zafiratos added a comment - 07/May/11 5:51 AM If the keys are in the ISO why hasn't it been hacked yet to run XBMC?
Hide
haveringcottage added a comment - 07/May/11 7:12 AM
this kind of discussion is probably best for the forum - forum.boxee.tv

This is the official boxee development issue tracker - not a discussion forum!
Show
haveringcottage added a comment - 07/May/11 7:12 AM this kind of discussion is probably best for the forum - forum.boxee.tv This is the official boxee development issue tracker - not a discussion forum!
Hide
lior added a comment - 07/May/11 7:30 AM
please continue this discussion on: http://forums.boxee.tv/showthread.php?p=183503
Show
lior added a comment - 07/May/11 7:30 AM please continue this discussion on: http://forums.boxee.tv/showthread.php?p=183503
Hide
hominid@gmail.com added a comment - 09/May/11 12:25 PM
+1 Airplay!
Show
hominid@gmail.com added a comment - 09/May/11 12:25 PM +1 Airplay!
Hide
Dhawal Sinha added a comment - 18/May/11 5:06 PM
+1
Show
Dhawal Sinha added a comment - 18/May/11 5:06 PM +1
Hide
Philip Chow added a comment - 18/May/11 8:55 PM
+1
Show
Philip Chow added a comment - 18/May/11 8:55 PM +1
Hide
ryan hendrix added a comment - 25/May/11 6:05 AM
+1. home has 5 televisions with apple tv. ready for a reason to switch all 5 tv's to boxee.
Show
ryan hendrix added a comment - 25/May/11 6:05 AM +1. home has 5 televisions with apple tv. ready for a reason to switch all 5 tv's to boxee.
Hide
Sindre added a comment - 07/Jun/11 6:13 PM
+1 AirPlaycis getting even more useful with Wireless Mirroring in iOS5. Please Boxee devs, can we please haz thiz?
Show
Sindre added a comment - 07/Jun/11 6:13 PM +1 AirPlaycis getting even more useful with Wireless Mirroring in iOS5. Please Boxee devs, can we please haz thiz?
Hide
Khoi Ky Pham added a comment - 08/Jun/11 9:55 AM
The boxee need to have this to be on top of the media player game. Iphone, ipad and ipod are the biggest portable media so having support for airplay is a must.


Show
Khoi Ky Pham added a comment - 08/Jun/11 9:55 AM The boxee need to have this to be on top of the media player game. Iphone, ipad and ipod are the biggest portable media so having support for airplay is a must.
Hide
Giovani Spagnolo added a comment - 09/Jun/11 7:21 AM
with iPad2 mirroring over wifi, could the boxee box and ipad become wii-killer ?
Show
Giovani Spagnolo added a comment - 09/Jun/11 7:21 AM with iPad2 mirroring over wifi, could the boxee box and ipad become wii-killer ?
Hide
jason added a comment - 25/Jun/11 12:48 AM
Let's get this done! this is the only thing keeping my apple TV plugged in. Would love to get it all into bb
Show
jason added a comment - 25/Jun/11 12:48 AM Let's get this done! this is the only thing keeping my apple TV plugged in. Would love to get it all into bb
Hide
wade added a comment - 26/Jun/11 4:25 PM
would love this
Show
wade added a comment - 26/Jun/11 4:25 PM would love this
Hide
brashers added a comment - 02/Jul/11 11:11 PM
I will give you 3,000,000,000,000,004.43 if you do it. Well, somewhere between that and nothing!
Show
brashers added a comment - 02/Jul/11 11:11 PM I will give you 3,000,000,000,000,004.43 if you do it. Well, somewhere between that and nothing!
Hide
Mike A added a comment - 07/Jul/11 2:22 PM

Would be a fantastic feature addition! I voted yes.
Show
Mike A added a comment - 07/Jul/11 2:22 PM Would be a fantastic feature addition! I voted yes.
Hide
Bilal Issa added a comment - 11/Jul/11 9:43 AM
Definitely a must have feature! I'm waiting for it...
Show
Bilal Issa added a comment - 11/Jul/11 9:43 AM Definitely a must have feature! I'm waiting for it...
Hide
nathan added a comment - 11/Jul/11 12:50 PM
I vote yes!
Show
nathan added a comment - 11/Jul/11 12:50 PM I vote yes!
Hide
Lucas Macedo added a comment - 14/Jul/11 1:35 AM
I use a lot of Apple stuff here and I would love see AirPlay on Boxee.
Show
Lucas Macedo added a comment - 14/Jul/11 1:35 AM I use a lot of Apple stuff here and I would love see AirPlay on Boxee.
Hide
Olly Stedall added a comment - 20/Jul/11 3:34 PM
+1 For my vote. Airfoil have just upgraded the 'Speaker' software to receive Audio. As a start, maybe integrating an airfoil client into boxee might be an advantage. :)
Show
Olly Stedall added a comment - 20/Jul/11 3:34 PM +1 For my vote. Airfoil have just upgraded the 'Speaker' software to receive Audio. As a start, maybe integrating an airfoil client into boxee might be an advantage. :)
Hide
Geir Borch added a comment - 27/Jul/11 5:19 AM
As IOS5 will have Airplay Mirroring check out a demo http://bit.ly/leQnzB, adding airplay to BB is even more important.
Show
Geir Borch added a comment - 27/Jul/11 5:19 AM As IOS5 will have Airplay Mirroring check out a demo http://bit.ly/leQnzB, adding airplay to BB is even more important.
Hide
haveringcottage added a comment - 27/Jul/11 5:25 AM
Yuval Tal [Boxee] added a comment - 05/May/11 2:55 PM
Apple is currently not licensing this for software companies.

is this still the official position or are any negotiations in progress? Has any work -at all- been done on this? Please can Boxee Staff comment or close the issue - just leaving it open is just stringing us along.
Show
haveringcottage added a comment - 27/Jul/11 5:25 AM Yuval Tal [Boxee] added a comment - 05/May/11 2:55 PM Apple is currently not licensing this for software companies. is this still the official position or are any negotiations in progress? Has any work -at all- been done on this? Please can Boxee Staff comment or close the issue - just leaving it open is just stringing us along.
Hide
Ryan Kelez added a comment - 27/Jul/11 5:39 AM
Hey, for those wondering yes apple will license AirPlay to companies but, it's currently at an extreme cost. Engadget posted an article a while ago about AirPlay adoption in a few high end (I'm talking 1k+) receivers from onkyo and the likes for home theatre systems. But these companies revealed the licensing cost was around 100$ per unit. This would make the boxee box 300$, at which point the Appletv is only $100 so what's the point.

Anyway I don't see boxee ever adding AirPlay due to that fee. I'd pay maybe 30$ for it max in a firmware update, but nothing more. It sucks but maybe in the future apple will loosen the restriction. I'm probably just going to get an Appletv and use it for NBA league pass and AirPlay every now and then.
Show
Ryan Kelez added a comment - 27/Jul/11 5:39 AM Hey, for those wondering yes apple will license AirPlay to companies but, it's currently at an extreme cost. Engadget posted an article a while ago about AirPlay adoption in a few high end (I'm talking 1k+) receivers from onkyo and the likes for home theatre systems. But these companies revealed the licensing cost was around 100$ per unit. This would make the boxee box 300$, at which point the Appletv is only $100 so what's the point. Anyway I don't see boxee ever adding AirPlay due to that fee. I'd pay maybe 30$ for it max in a firmware update, but nothing more. It sucks but maybe in the future apple will loosen the restriction. I'm probably just going to get an Appletv and use it for NBA league pass and AirPlay every now and then.
Hide
haveringcottage added a comment - 27/Jul/11 6:25 AM
THanks for the info Ryan - But can boxee confirm or deny this?
Show
haveringcottage added a comment - 27/Jul/11 6:25 AM THanks for the info Ryan - But can boxee confirm or deny this?
Hide
Ryan Kelez added a comment - 27/Jul/11 6:45 AM
No clue, they're usually pretty quiet on stuff so probably not?? Google about AirPlay Support next time ya get a chance and I'm sure toll find something. I did like a month or two ago when I saw that info.
Show
Ryan Kelez added a comment - 27/Jul/11 6:45 AM No clue, they're usually pretty quiet on stuff so probably not?? Google about AirPlay Support next time ya get a chance and I'm sure toll find something. I did like a month or two ago when I saw that info.
Hide
Geir Borch added a comment - 27/Jul/11 6:52 AM - edited
@Ryan: I don't think info about the license price for Airplay is correct. I did some searching and most articles say the price for the airplay license (sound only) is $4 pr unit.
There are several articles now saying that Apple will maybe start licensing out the videopart of Airplay soon, but no price is mentioned. Here is a example : http://bit.ly/nj2bXq
The videopart is ready, but has to be enabled first.
This article refers to the $4 price and also to the video part licensing : http://macdailynews.com/2011/03/23/apple-considers-licensing-airplay-for-streaming-video-to-ce-makers/
Show
Geir Borch added a comment - 27/Jul/11 6:52 AM - edited @Ryan: I don't think info about the license price for Airplay is correct. I did some searching and most articles say the price for the airplay license (sound only) is $4 pr unit. There are several articles now saying that Apple will maybe start licensing out the videopart of Airplay soon, but no price is mentioned. Here is a example : http://bit.ly/nj2bXq The videopart is ready, but has to be enabled first. This article refers to the $4 price and also to the video part licensing : http://macdailynews.com/2011/03/23/apple-considers-licensing-airplay-for-streaming-video-to-ce-makers/
Hide
Ryan Kelez added a comment - 27/Jul/11 7:00 AM
Well f me sideways maybe I was drunk or something I've been under the impression it was crazy expensive.

Boxee, get off your ass and add support! I'll pay $4 for audio now and you can keep my card on file if they allow video later.

That's super cheap. Now I don't have a clue why we don't have any support or at least a word from boxee about this. Especially with how popular this request is. And since they're licensing it I assume there wouldn't be much coding to do. I'll hold off on that Appletv a bit longer, at least until ios5 I guess.

Show
Ryan Kelez added a comment - 27/Jul/11 7:00 AM Well f me sideways maybe I was drunk or something I've been under the impression it was crazy expensive. Boxee, get off your ass and add support! I'll pay $4 for audio now and you can keep my card on file if they allow video later. That's super cheap. Now I don't have a clue why we don't have any support or at least a word from boxee about this. Especially with how popular this request is. And since they're licensing it I assume there wouldn't be much coding to do. I'll hold off on that Appletv a bit longer, at least until ios5 I guess.
Hide
Kyle Bjordahl added a comment - 08/Aug/11 3:51 AM
+1 For Airplay as well. Have been using Airfoil for a couple of years, but would love to see actual Apple Airplay included. On one hand, I can see why apple wouldn't want a competitor including it, but on the other hand, it would mean that more people might find themselves with an Airplay-compatible device at home, and then start using the ITMS for content, which is what Apple really wants.
Show
Kyle Bjordahl added a comment - 08/Aug/11 3:51 AM +1 For Airplay as well. Have been using Airfoil for a couple of years, but would love to see actual Apple Airplay included. On one hand, I can see why apple wouldn't want a competitor including it, but on the other hand, it would mean that more people might find themselves with an Airplay-compatible device at home, and then start using the ITMS for content, which is what Apple really wants.
Hide
Rafael Mizrahi [Boxee] added a comment - 09/Aug/11 11:58 AM
closed. verified using 1.2.0.20310
Show
Rafael Mizrahi [Boxee] added a comment - 09/Aug/11 11:58 AM closed. verified using 1.2.0.20310
Hide
Chad Augustine added a comment - 16/Aug/11 9:36 PM
Hey Boxee team, love the new iPad app and media server. Pretty Slick!

I think there might have been some confusion on this request -- maybe on my part??? Don't get me wrong, I love the new IPad app, but I would like to see you take it one step further.

When playing a song on your iPad via the music library (the iPod app) you chose which "AirTunes" device you a streaming too. Maybe its the iPad internal speakers, maybe it's the apple tv (which I sold by the way as soon as I got my boxee) or maybe it's an airport device. Any chance we can get the boxee to show up in that list?

Thanks again for the hard work, can't wait to see what you have in store next'
Show
Chad Augustine added a comment - 16/Aug/11 9:36 PM Hey Boxee team, love the new iPad app and media server. Pretty Slick! I think there might have been some confusion on this request -- maybe on my part??? Don't get me wrong, I love the new IPad app, but I would like to see you take it one step further. When playing a song on your iPad via the music library (the iPod app) you chose which "AirTunes" device you a streaming too. Maybe its the iPad internal speakers, maybe it's the apple tv (which I sold by the way as soon as I got my boxee) or maybe it's an airport device. Any chance we can get the boxee to show up in that list? Thanks again for the hard work, can't wait to see what you have in store next'
Hide
Pat added a comment - 16/Aug/11 9:45 PM
Chad: That exact feature is in the latest firmware. You have to enable it on the boxee box under settings. I don't know why it's off by default, but I assume they have their reasons.
Show
Pat added a comment - 16/Aug/11 9:45 PM Chad: That exact feature is in the latest firmware. You have to enable it on the boxee box under settings. I don't know why it's off by default, but I assume they have their reasons.
Hide
Kyle Bjordahl added a comment - 16/Aug/11 9:50 PM
The Firmware update works for me, as far as streaming from an iOS device, but from my iMac running Lion, it shows up as an Airport Express, but won't allow me to select it.
Show
Kyle Bjordahl added a comment - 16/Aug/11 9:50 PM The Firmware update works for me, as far as streaming from an iOS device, but from my iMac running Lion, it shows up as an Airport Express, but won't allow me to select it.
Hide
Chad Augustine added a comment - 16/Aug/11 10:41 PM
@ Pat. I am typing tthis comment from my iPad while it's streaming music to my boxee!!! Thanks, that's exactly what I was looking for, everything works great.

Show
Chad Augustine added a comment - 16/Aug/11 10:41 PM @ Pat. I am typing tthis comment from my iPad while it's streaming music to my boxee!!! Thanks, that's exactly what I was looking for, everything works great.

People

Vote (287)
Watch (90)

Dates

  • Created:
    17/Dec/10 4:34 PM
    Updated:
    16/Aug/11 10:41 PM
    Resolved:
    09/Aug/11 11:30 AM